Who first noticed a sign that Andy was dead?

• A. Tyrone
• B. BJ
• C. Gerald
• D. Monty

Answer: (D)

Monty is the first to recognize the grave reality of the situation, which is why this moment stands out in the story. In the tense aftermath, he notices the lack of life signs in Andy and realizes that Andy isn’t simply unconscious or okay—he’s dead. That immediate, clear perception makes him the first to acknowledge the tragedy, and his realization sets off the group’s subsequent reaction and decisions. This moment highlights how quickly fear and uncertainty can give way to a stark truth, and it foreshadows the guilt, pressure, and moral choices the boys will face as they grapple with what to do next.